It's still a dumb idea.
a .410 revolver is dumb. It was tried before with the MIL Thunder Five, and it was a market failure. So, Taurus copies it a few years ago with the idiotic Judge. They put some serious (and misleading) marketing behind it and prove PT Barnum right.
S&W sees a lot of dollars going to a dubious concept, so they pull a 'Me Too'. They tweak it to run with .45ACP as well as .410 and .45Colt. But what they end up with is still just a copy of a copy of a market failure.
And the naming of these things... The Judge and The Governor? Seriously?